Epiloge
This paper revealed that
natural systems do not follow human, made rule making. This becomes, in
particular, true for regulatory aspects in nuclear waste management. Long term projects like the Yucca
Mountain nation's repository program is a good example of how difficult it is to
predict its safe operation over a longer time period. The performance of the repository was initially based on
physical criteria (e.g., geological barriers)
which, however, encountered scientific objections triggered by the set time frame of the
repository operation phase (e.g., at least 10,000 years and longer) vs.
the safety to humans and the environment. The political constellations were also
questioned such as administrative control over the
repository in the future. The initial
evaluation process of single subsystem performance (e.g., rock erosion) was finally
replaced with evaluating the whole system including human, engineered
constructions. These constructions were
to control and mitigate possible safety problems (e.g., water impact on the repository). The new approach of evaluating the repository performance was favorable and assumed a better predictability of the
repository performance. A better predictability of the repository performance made it more reasonable of meeting licensing
requirements and building and operating the repository within the given deadlines of the Nuclear Waste Policy Act. The reader might further discuss the
usefulness of nuclear waste in the future.
In deed, the waste might become “gold” when the waste might be converted
into something useful and harmless by a new and inexpensive technology. Yet developing technologies and economics of such type is still far from our
capacities. Thus the question of continuing nuclear energy might then be treated as a moral one. In other words creating new “pyramids” of waste does
not hold with our primary philosophy of humanity and life (Protection of life). Waste of such long time, toxic
effect ought not to be produced or accepted by economic priorities or international competition. A single
terrestrial or extraterrestrial incident may be enough to release the waste to
the biosphere and generate irreversible consequences to life and environment
for many thousand years of time. In fact, the expenses will exceed profits at high cost for humanity and life.